Chef Matt Kern: A Culinary Conservationist
Matt Kern’s 2012 Toyota Tundra is a familiar sight in Delmarva farms’ driveways. For instance, en route to his Fenwick Island restaurant, One Coastal, he might stop at Story Hill Farm to buy milk for his ricotta cheese. Next up is Bennett Orchards, where he might pick up blueberries and peaches, and then it’s on to East View Farms for mushrooms and produce.
While many chefs profess to take a farm-to-table approach, Kern “walks the walk,” says Ryan Richard, co-owner of East View Farms. “He buys so much from farmers, local fishermen and other local vendors—he’s one of my biggest supporters, and he’s easy to work with.”
The fresh ingredients combined with Kern’s skillful preparation and knack for plating demonstrate why he is a 2024 James Beard finalist for Best Chef Mid-Atlantic. Bestowed by the esteemed James Beard Foundation, the honor is the equivalent of a culinary Oscar. Kern was a semi-finalist in 2019 and 2020 while working at Heirloom in Lewes. However, this was his first time as a finalist, a recognition made sweeter given he has his own restaurant. On June 10, the award went to Chef Harley Peet (another Delmarva chef). But Kern does not need an award to be a winner.
A love for the land
The Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, native developed an interest in agriculture after his grandmother taught him to care for rhubarb. “She made a strawberry-rhubarb pie, and I loved it,” Kern recalls. She also thought nothing of walking a mile to get butcher bacon for her bacon-tomato sandwiches. “There was no lettuce; she said it got in the way,” he notes. Meanwhile, her boyfriend taught him to fish for trout, catfish and bass, a hobby he still avidly pursues in the Pennsylvania mountains. (He won’t keep his catch unless he can eat it fresh. “I don’t like frozen fish,” he explains.)
At 14, Kern didn’t have many friends. “I was in my own little world,” he says. That changed when he got a job in a restaurant kitchen. He moved up the line without cutting corners, which was the expected path in the 1990s and early 2000s; there was no time or money for culinary school.
While at Starfish Brasserie in Bethlehem, Kern admired Chef Dick Barrows’ use of farm-fresh ingredients. At Edge restaurant, also in Bethlehem, Chef Tim Widrick used local goods. Then, at Bolete, he met farmer Jeff Frank of Liberty Gardens. “He came in two or three times a week with dirty hands and a big old smile,” Kern recalls. “He grew some of the coolest things I’ve seen to date—wild fennel flowers, all these different leaves and lamb’s quarter, which is so tasty, but most people can’t identify it.”
At Bolete, Kern was impressed by Lee Chizmar’s “from scratch” approach to cooking. The chef also butchered whole animals in the restaurant rather than purchasing packaged cuts and avoided waste.
From chef to owner
Kern moved to Delaware beaches to work for a Bethlehem-based restaurant group, but the downtown Rehoboth restaurant didn’t survive one summer. Although far from Lehigh Valley's hills and trout streams, Kern elected to stay at the beach. The reason? He’d fallen in love with a local girl, Karen, who would become his wife.
He worked at Bluecoast Seafood Grill, Blue Moon, and Salt Air, all the while wanting to run a kitchen committed to sustainability. When Jordan Miller left Heirloom, Kern saw a chance to work in a high-end restaurant with a sparkling new kitchen. While cooking in the Lewes restaurant, Kern received two James Beard nominations.
Kern’s summer commute from his Dagsboro home wasn’t easy. What’s more, Heirloom was the vision of owner Meghan Lee. The two parted ways, and Kern considered moving to a city. Then he learned that One Coastal in Fenwick Island was going up for sale.
In 2022, Kern and his wife, Karen, purchased the intimate eatery from Scott and Carlie Carey. The Careys opened it in 2014 to support local agriculture and took the concept further by growing organic produce on their 25-acre Frankford property.
The Kerns admired the restaurant’s mission and met with the sellers before it hit the market. In August, Kern became the executive chef while One Coastal traded hands, and all the licensing was complete.
One Coastal’s kitchen reminded the new owner of Bolete. The small space lacks Heirloom’s bells and whistles, such as a sous vide machine, vacuum sealer, and deep fryer. (The chef won’t make soft-shell crabs—his favorite—because he doesn’t feel he can cook them properly in a pan.)
“I remembered what I did at Bolete under Lee [Chizmar]," Kern says of using ingenuity to make “less” turn into “more.” “I’ve always been the underdog. I like figuring things out, which means using what’s in season to produce the best flavors.
Kern still buys produce from the Careys’ farm. Other vendors include East View Farms and Baywater Farms in Salisbury, Maryland. This approach is what turned The Lost Kitchen in Freedom, Maine, into a reservation-only destination with a TV program.
Kern is a fan of owner Erin French, who cleverly makes do with whatever her growers can provide. For instance, when Kern had trouble finding salad greens, he purchased whatever field greens East View provide, including beet greens, baby romaine, pea tendrils and lamb’s quarter. He tossed the mix with Fifer Orchard strawberries, house-made ricotta, and honey-vinegar dressing. He also puts leftover herbs in salads. “It adds more flavor and texture,” he notes.
The waste-not-want-not philosophy might lead to a garnish of fried carrot peelings. “Take an ingredient and figure out 20 or 30 things to do with it,” he says. “It helps you build the menu but still cross-utilize ingredients.”
Making a difference
Kern is a big man with a gentle voice, and his advice falls softly but convincingly on his staff’s ears. “He is not the type of chef to scream at you in hopes that it will encourage better behavior,” says pastry chef Skylar Crowley. “His approach is one of complete mentorship.”
Carrie Leishman would agree. She is president and CEO of the Delaware Restaurant Association, and Kern has been involved in the association’s Delaware ProStart program, a high school culinary curriculum and competition. “He’s one of our influential judges,” she explains. “He really commits and is very thoughtful to those students and the next generation.”
Kern tearfully credited his team when he learned he was a James Beard semifinalist. “I have put everything into this tiny 50-seat strip mall restaurant—everything. I’ve spent God knows how many hours believing in this place—painting, struggling, failing, thriving, teaching, and believing in my staff—just to be able to do this on my own terms,” he explained at the time.
Secret diners visited the restaurant to narrow the semifinalist pool. However, Kern didn’t spot any familiar faces in the crowd. He simply continued preparing six or seven appetizers, up to eight entrees and vegetarian dishes featuring the season's flavors.
And with each course, he teaches his team. One day, he maintains, they will be even better than he is. It’s about skill and passion, Crowley says.
“He is not only an amazing chef, but he’s an amazing man who puts his all into everything,” she concludes. “His love and devotion to almost everything in his life is admirable, and I am very blessed to have learned and worked under him.”
One Coastal
101 Coastal Highway, Fenwick Island, Delaware, 302.537.4790
Facebook Instagram
Tues-Sun, 5-9 pm